
“Maybe it might be better just to say, ‘Well, if it is another two, three weeks, does that really make a difference?’”
On the preliminary election results, the existing coalition holds a narrow majority, with 67 of the 131 seats in Parliament. But that could yet change when the official count, including about 400,000 special votes, is published on November 27.
Asked to reflect on the result, Brownlee acknowledged National’s low party support – just 29% – but pointed to its success in 42 electorates.
“[That] does not indicate any lack of confidence in a political party.”
He suggested that National’s support had taken a hit because of the influence of its partners in the three-way coalition, including concessions like Act’s Treaty Principles Bill.
“There were some decisions made that perhaps the wider population didn’t really appreciate,” he said.
“Sometimes those things overshadow the good things that were done.”
Brownlee would not say whether National had given away too much in the negotiations three years ago, saying he had not been in the room.
Brownlee floats MMP shake-up
Brownlee also nodded towards the effect of strategic voting on National’s support, saying the discussion appeared to empower or encourage people to split their vote.
“Clearly people want to have a dollar each way.”
Brownlee said that practice could lead to much larger overhangs and Parliaments in future.
He said MMP could do with “a little bit of work” to address that. He suggested a different electoral model altogether, known as the Supplementary Member system, where the party vote would determine only the allocation of list seats, rather than the make-up of Parliament as a whole.
As an example, Brownlee said Parliament could have 60 electorate MPs and 60 list MPs. A party winning 30% of the vote would receive 18 list MPs, on top of the electorates it won.
Such a change would prevent the kind of overhang seen this election but would likely result in smaller parties receiving significantly fewer MPs.
New Zealanders opted against replacing MMP in a 2011 referendum, with 58% backing the existing system and 42% voting for change.
Voters were also asked which alternative they preferred: First Past the Post topped the list with 47% of valid votes, followed by Supplementary Member on 24%.
That Supplementary Member model proposed 90 electorate seats and 30 list seats.
– RNZ
